Hi, I've been lurking on this site for more than one year, but this is the first time I post a message. Kirstie, I think I also bought from the same grower some Catt seedlings in the NYIOS (just from the tag and the container). Mine are not bad, I got them on Friday and immediately removed the packing materials, and I wait a few days before watering them. I did notice there are dirt like stuff coming out of the 2" pot when I soaked them. I decided to repot one and it turned out most of the bark were broken down into tiny particles, maybe not from decompsing, but from termite damages. So you might as well repot yours if you see the same fine dirt came out from your pot or if the plant can easily be detached from the pot.