I am going to go with a phal since many new growers may not be able to provide high enough light for some of the other orchids on the list. Plus, I have practical experience with phals and semi-hydro and know it works like magic!
Cheers,
BD
Welcome to OrchidTalk Orchid Forums
The Friendliest Orchid Community on the Internet!
OrchidTalk - "Bringing People Together to Grow Orchids Better!"
Let us help you grow your Orchids better; Join our community today.
YES! I want to register an account for free right now!
Register or Login now to remove this advertisement.
Phal
Paph
Phrag
Onc
Intergenic
Catt
Vanda
Other
Okay all you experts out there, if a person wanted to try s/h for the first time which orchid would you suggest as a trial plant?
I am going to go with a phal since many new growers may not be able to provide high enough light for some of the other orchids on the list. Plus, I have practical experience with phals and semi-hydro and know it works like magic!
Cheers,
BD
I went with a Phal. not an expensive one , some seem to like it some not I have 2 or 3 in s/h that love it but removed a couple that did not do well in it . I think it has a lot to do with the plant , some are robust growers root wise and some not . Just my 2 cents worth . Next pick would be a Phrag. Gin
I'm going against the grain here..
but I say an oncidium or an onc intergeneric is pretty easy. It takes them a couple of months to get established, but once they do they become worry free plants...
I agree with everyone above - my order would be 1. Phal, 2. oncid, and 3.phrag. I've been growing in S&H, and I have *everything* in S&H simply because I don't have time to water as much as I would like, and everything is doing swimmingly. My phals in S&H grow these amazingly long, robust green roots - I love looking at them through the container (I keep my plants in Poland Spring 3 liter water jugs after I'm done drinking the water, I cut off the top, haha...) Its really fun! Give it a try :-)
I have only got one plant in S/H currently (a paph) but I have also voted for phal since you can get them really cheap so it won't leave that much of a hole in the budget if it decides not to do well. I've just ordered some LECA and I'll be trying a phrag and phal next so we'll see how it turns out.
I moved two phrags over to s/h since they hadn't done much for a couple of years. They've responded well with new growths on both in just 3 months. So I vote phrags.
I have a Phrag and two Phals in s/h and both types are loving it.
Hm, my phal in S/H evenutally succumbed so I am going to second the oncidium/intergeneric vote here (hard to choose one) - my Colmonara is going crazy and S/H totally saved by rootless Onc. "Sweet Sugar".
My phal in s/h is also growing quite well, but the speed, new growth, and root growth of the colmonara tops them all!
I've never had any luck with s/h -- killed any orchid I tried it on. *sigh*